Cheese Pizza
10" $12 · 16" $18. Add any of 17 toppings.
New York‑Style Pizza in Cape Coral
Hand‑tossed pies in 10‑inch and 16‑inch sizes, a 16‑by‑16 Sicilian and a pizza of the month, on Cape Coral Parkway since 1990.
Papa Joe's makes hand‑tossed New York‑style pizza on Cape Coral Parkway, from $12 for a 10‑inch cheese pie.
- Sizes
- 10" and 16"
- Cheese pizza
- $12 and $18
- Sicilian 16" x 16"
- $24
- Pickup
- (239) 945-1700
Something for every table
Brooklyn Pizza
Mozzarella, fresh chopped tomatoes, basil and olive oil. 10" $13 · 16" $20.
Papa Joe's Deluxe
Any four toppings. 10" $15 · 16" $25.
White Pizza
Fresh garlic, olive oil and mozzarella. 10" $12 · 16" $18.
Sicilian
A 16" x 16" square pie for $24. Allow 40 minutes to cook.
Pizza of the Month
Ask your server or call to hear this month's pie.
Common questions
Where can I get New York‑style pizza in Cape Coral?
Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria at 814 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL 33904 has made hand-tossed New York-style pizza on Cape Coral Parkway since 1990. Dine in, sit on the covered patio, or call (239) 945-1700 for pickup.
How much is a pizza at Papa Joe's?
A 10-inch cheese pizza is $12 and a 16-inch is $18. Specialty pies like the Brooklyn and Papa Joe's Deluxe run $13 to $25, and the 16-by-16-inch Sicilian is $24.
What sizes are Papa Joe's pizzas?
Round pizzas come in 10-inch and 16-inch sizes. The Sicilian is a 16-by-16-inch square pie that takes about 40 minutes to cook.
Can I order a whole pizza for pickup?
Yes. Call (239) 945-1700 Tuesday through Saturday from 4 PM and pick up your pies at the restaurant on Cape Coral Parkway East.
Does Papa Joe's make white pizza?
Yes. Papa Joe's white pizza is made with fresh garlic, olive oil and mozzarella. Add ricotta for $6.
Does Papa Joe's cater pizza for parties?
Yes. Papa Joe's caters pizza, baked pasta and salads for parties and offices in Cape Coral. Call (239) 945-1700 to plan an order.
Anything else? Call (239) 945-1700
Dinner Tuesday to Saturday from 4 PM
Call ahead for pickup or join us on Cape Coral Parkway.